Utah's Housing Shortage: Myth vs. Reality

Uncover the truth behind Utah's housing "shortage" myth and what it really means for home buyers and sellers in 2025.

You've probably heard the headlines: "America is short 6 million homes!" But here's what those studies aren't telling you about what's happening right now in Utah's housing market.

Table of Contents

Housing Shortage Studies and Reality

A new analysis from the American Enterprise Institute claims the U.S. has a massive housing shortage, with places like California and New York leading the pack. These studies make for compelling headlines. But while they can be predictors of long-term price movements, they're surprisingly poor predictors of short-term market conditions.

This map shows where researchers claim the biggest shortages exist - notice how they align perfectly with the most expensive markets.

Here's the eye-opening truth: Many markets labeled as having the biggest "shortages" are actually experiencing the softest conditions right now, while areas with supposedly no shortage at all are seeing the tightest inventory.

AEI's housing "shortage" estimates

Current active inventory vs. 2019 levels

See the disconnect? Markets with supposed "shortages" often have rising inventory, while "no shortage" areas are tight.

What This Means for Utah

The Short-Term Reality: Utah currently has 22.3% more inventory than we had in 2019 – before the pandemic housing frenzy. This means more choices for buyers and a more balanced market where homes aren't flying off the market, buyers have more negotiating leverage, and both buyers and sellers are finding it matters what type of agent you work with.

The Long-Term Picture: Utah still benefits from strong population growth, job creation, and limited developable land – genuine long-term tailwinds that support housing demand. These fundamentals haven't disappeared; they're just temporarily overshadowed by higher inventory levels.

The Bottom Line for You

Whether you're buying or selling, don't let headlines drive your decisions. The market is nuanced, and expert help matters enormously.

For Sellers: The days of bidding wars may be behind us, but quality homes are still selling. Pricing and presentation are more important than ever. In fact, I’m sharing with many of my seller clients how we’re able to position their home so we manufacture a sellers market for their home, even while being in a overall buyer’s market.

For Buyers: You have more negotiating power and time to make thoughtful decisions than you've had in years. Interest rates may be higher, but you also have less competition and more options to choose from, which can lead to finding great deals.

Ready to navigate this shifting market? Whether you're thinking of buying, selling, or just want to understand what these changes mean for your specific situation, I'm here to help you cut through the noise and make informed decisions.

Let's chat about your housing goals – call me at (801) 830-2175 or reply to this email. In this market, having the right strategy makes all the difference.

Here to serve,

Dustyn Haug
REALTOR®
Personal:(801) 830-2175
Other:(385) 412-7310
Email:[email protected]
Site:www.atm.homes

P.S. You owe me nothing. But if you know anyone considering a move in the next 6-12 months, I'd love to an introduction. This market shift is creating opportunities, but they require the right guidance to capitalize on them.